Copy Cat Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups {Sugar Free}

The links in this post may be affiliate links. Read the full disclosure policy.

I’ve tried skinny chocolate with peanut butter in the middle but it’s just not the same as a Reese’s peanut butter cup.  The peanut butter in the candy bar has a creamier, sweeter taste.  This is my version of the popular candy bar but sugar-free. I used a mini muffin pan to make these. It helps to keep these cups candy bar sized.

I love Hershey’s chocolate but not in my skinny chocolate.  To make it taste more like the candy bar, I use Ghirardelli Unsweetened Cocoa.  I’m not normally a picky person, but the difference it makes is HUGE in my opinion. 

I use a combination of Truvia and xylitol in this recipe but they are interchangeable and you can use whichever you have on hand.  Xylitol measures cup for cup like sugar. Truvia is a bit sweeter than xylitol.  Here is a chart for converting sugar and Truvia

Copy Cat Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (Sugar- Free)

Printable Recipe

Peanut Butter Middle:

1/3 cup peanut butter
1/3 cup peanut flour
4 Tbs. (half stick) butter, melted
2/3 cup Truvia, ground in blender (or if you like less sweetener, you can use 1/3 cup Truvia and another 1/3 cup peanut flour)


1/2 cup cocoa powder (I highly recommend Ghirardelli)
1 cup coconut oil, melted (I used refined so there was no coconut taste)
2/3 cup xylitol, ground in blender (can substitute Truvia or stevia to taste)

For the Peanut Butter Middle, mix all ingredients together in a small bowl.  Put in fridge to chill while making the chocolate.  For the chocolate, melt coconut oil (if solidified) in microwave.  Put in small bowl and mix with cocoa powder and xylitol with a whisk.  Put about 1/2 Tbs. of chocolate in each baking cup.  Take small amount of peanut butter mix (about 1 teaspoon) and shape it to fit in the cup.  Pour chocolate over the peanut butter until it is covered.  Freeze until solidified.  You can store in the freezer or fridge.  I prefer the fridge as it is easier to eat.

Makes about 24 mini peanut butter cups

THM Notes:  This is an S dessert

Join me on Facebook and Twitter where I share coupons, deals, recipes and more! 

This post is linked to Saturday Night Fever, Sweet & Savoury Sunday, Random Recipe Roundup, Motivate Me Monday, Mouthwatering Mondays, Melt in Your Mouth Monday, Show me What you Got, In and Out of the Kitchen, The Gathering Spot, Wonderful Wednesday, Wonderfully Creative Wednesdays, Cast Party Wednesday, Allergy Free Wednesdays, Gluten Free Wednesdays, Lovely Ladies Linky, Wellness Wednesday, Create it Thursday, Full Plate Thursday, Gluten Free Fridays, Weekend Re-Treat , Friday Frenzy, Simple Meal Fridays, Whole Food Fridays, Weekend Potluck, Strut Your Stuff, Super Saturday Link Party, Saturday SHOWlicious Party.


    • Eva says

      I don’t count calories or carbs for the most part but I just did an internet search to find that there are 3 carbs in 1 tablespoon of peanut butter and 1 carb in 1 tablespoon peanut flour. You’d have to check the carb count of the sweetener you use. Sorry that I can’t be of more help!

  1. Crystal says

    Does this taste like milk chocolate? I’ve tried making the skinny chocolate and it tasted horrible. It was so bitter and just tasted like straight cocoa. I don’t like dark chocolate at all, I love milk chocolate and peanut butter cups are one of my favorites. It’s been so disappointing I can’t get my chocolate fix because everything I try tastes like dark chocolate. :(

    • Eva says

      I understand what you are saying. It took me awhile to get the skinny chocolate right since I also love milk chocolate. The biggest difference was when I switched to Ghirardelli for the skinny chocolate instead of Hershey’s. I love Hershey’s in my chocolate syrup but not in skinny chocolate. I also used xylitol which tastes more like sugar than stevia. Trust me, I am picky about my chocolate and I am in love with these peanut butter cups. :) Some people also add heavy cream to their skinny chocolate but I didn’t find that necessary once I made the two changes I mentioned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge